If You Don’t Have Reviews: Where to Start

The review process can feel overwhelming, outdated or disconnected from daily work. For these reasons, many teams skip them altogether, not because they don't care about performance but because they're not sure where to start.

But here’s the truth: a great performance review process doesn’t start with forms. It starts with conversations.

When done well, reviews help employees pause, reflect, and realign. They give teams space to celebrate wins, talk about what’s next, and turn everyday feedback into meaningful progress.

If you don’t have performance reviews yet, the best place to begin isn’t with a template. It’s with trust.

Performance reviews are not about compliance. They are about connection and development.
They create a rhythm for learning and accountability, giving employees and managers a shared checkpoint to look at growth, goals, and future potential together.

Without a review process:

• Employees often miss the bigger picture of how their work contributes to team and organizational goals.
• Managers lose the chance to spot growth opportunities early.
• Over time, performance can drift simply because no one is pausing long enough to see the pattern.

A well-structured review framework builds alignment, encourages honest feedback, and helps everyone focus on what matters most: improvement and development.

Before you start a performance review process, you need a habit of ongoing, meaningful conversations.
Begin with regular 1:1 meetings between managers and employees. These are your building blocks.

Use these 1:1s to:

• Talk about goals, challenges, and wins
• Capture notes about progress and growth areas
• Identify patterns over time that can later inform reviews

If you’re using miviva, use 1:1 agendas and notes to track what’s discussed and agreed upon. If not, a shared document or spreadsheet works fine. The key is consistency.

Start small. While once a week is best, if you can't manage that yet, aim for biweekly or monthly 1:1s. Once those conversations feel natural, you’ll have the insight and trust you need to move into a more formal review framework.

Now you’re ready to build a performance review process that fits your organization.

Start light. Focus on starting with progress, not perfection. A simple review template with three sections is often enough:

• Strengths: What’s going well?
• Growth areas: What could be developed further?
• Next steps: What goals or skills should come next?

Hold your first review after about three months of consistent 1:1s. The goal isn’t to rate performance. It’s to reflect on progress and co-create a development plan for what’s next.

Focus on how to conduct performance reviews as coaching conversations, not compliance checklists. Encourage employees to share their reflections first. This turns the meeting into a genuine performance development conversation.

If you’re using miviva, capture these reflections directly in your 1:1 or in a shared document to build continuity between discussions.

Once you’ve completed a few review cycles, gather feedback.
Ask employees and managers what felt useful and what didn’t. Then refine your performance review framework accordingly, and share updates with leaders in order to get their feedback.

Start adding layers only when the basics are strong:

• Introduce mid-year and annual reviews
• Hold calibration sessions with other managers for fairness and consistency
• Incorporate goal progress and key results

Use metrics from miviva or a shared dashboard to track completion rates, goal progress, and common development themes across the organization. The data should spark conversations and action, not just fill reports.

• Conduct 1:1s weekly or biweekly.
• Establish developmental performance reviews once the 1:1s are in place. Review can happen every six months or annually.
• Establish manager calibration annually or after each review cycle.

These checkpoints help make performance reviews an ongoing rhythm, not a one-time event.

Starting a review process does not have to be complicated.
When you build from conversations instead of compliance, reviews become an opportunity for growth, not a task to dread.

Every organization can start somewhere. All it takes is one intentional conversation, one simple framework, and the commitment to keep improving.

Performance Review Starter Roadmap
Your step-by-step guide to creating a simple, development-focused review process that grows with your team.

Download Now

• Get started with 1:1s: If You Don’t Have 1:1s: Where to Start
• Get started with goals: If You Don’t Have Goals: Where to Start
• Return to the main hub? Where to Start with Performance Management